I had a handful of these tiny plush as a kid, the shiny fabric was always appealing to me. Caterpie is not the rarest out of them all, but he is far up on the list, very rarely going for under 50.00. This one I bought in Canterbury Village (a now-defunct toy shop where I live) around the Christmas season of 2000.
Applause Charmeleon Plush
Availability: Scarce (6)
Found him in a 25 cent bin at a garage sale. It's not very often I find these plush, and this is one that tends to be all over the map in terms of value.
Applause Dratini Plush
Availability- Uncommon (5)
Please excuse the terrible quality of poor Dratini, the majority of the plush I currently own from this set are ones I've had since I was very little and I guess I thought they were bath toys at the time...But yeah after a few times of that, poor Dratini's sticker eyes wore away and my mom was nice enough to draw him on new ones.
Applause Meowth Plush
Availability- Common (3)
Applause Psyduck Plush
Availability- Moderate (4)
I shelled out more for this little guy than I usually pay, at a flea market nonetheless, but I barely ever see these so I bought it on impulse.
Applause Squirtle Plush
Availability- Common (3)
Applause Vulpix Plush
Availability- Moderate (4)
Another plush that required serious "eye replacement surgery" with help from my mum
This is one of the few Vulpix plushies that's common to find in the wild, alongside the KFC plush.